A first rhinoplasty consultation works best when you arrive prepared. In short, verify the surgeon's board certification, study before and after photos of noses similar to yours, have a timeline for when you want surgery, confirm financials, bring photos, medical records, and a written list of questions.
Interest in nose surgery is widespread. The International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery ranked rhinoplasty among the top five surgical cosmetic procedures worldwide in 2024. ISAPS Global Survey 2024 With so many surgeons offering it in Manhattan, a structured approach to the first visit helps you judge fit with confidence.
Dr. Richard Westreich, a double board-certified facial plastic surgeon on the Upper East Side, has performed more than 4,000 facial surgeries over two decades of practice. This guide draws on his approach to explain what a first visit involves.
How to Choose the Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in NYC: A Step-by-Step Checklist
The best rhinoplasty surgeon in NYC for you is the one who passes four checks, completed in this order before any deposit is paid.
- Verify certification: Confirm the surgeon is board certified in a specialty that fits nasal surgery, then check the credential with the certifying board rather than relying on a website badge. Rhinoplasty surgeons commonly hold certification through one or more of these boards:
- American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
- American Board of Plastic Surgery
- American Board of Otolaryngology
Dr. Westreich is double board-certified, pairing facial plastic surgery with ENT(Otolarygology) training. That combination matters because the nose is both a facial feature and part of the airway.
- Review before and afters for similar noses: Look for patients whose starting anatomy, skin thickness, and ethnic features resemble yours, and judge whether results look natural from the front, side, and angled views. The practice's rhinoplasty before and after gallery is a good place to start.
- Confirm the surgical facility: Ask whether the operation takes place in the practice's own surgical center or at an outside hospital, and whether the facility is accredited. Dr. Westreich performs rhinoplasty at New Face NY's surgical center.
- Ask about revision rate and technique preference: Ask how often the surgeon's patients need a second procedure and whether the surgeon favors an open or closed approach. Dr. Westreich prefers the closed approach, which uses incisions inside the nostrils, and reserves open rhinoplasty for specific technical reasons. He also originated Foundation Rhinoplasty™, a closed technique for noses with septal deviation or facial asymmetry. Ultimately, equivalent results can be obtained by different surgeons, provided their analysis and strategy are similar. Approach is not a significant factor in outcomes - it all about the plan.
Revision experience carries real weight. In the AAFPRS 2024 Annual Trends Survey, about 80 percent of member surgeons reported that more than 10 percent of their rhinoplasty patients were seeking revision of an earlier operation. Dr. Westreich’s Revision Rhinoplasty practice is roughly 30-40% of his cases and his personal revision rate is less than 1%.
What to Bring to Your Rhinoplasty Consultation
Bring four things to a rhinoplasty consultation in NYC: photos, your medical history, your questions, and insurance information if breathing is part of your concern.
- Photos of your desired outcome: Save a handful of images of noses you admire, plus a few clear photos of your own nose from the front and side. Note what you like in each reference, whether that is the bridge line, the tip shape, or overall proportion.
- Medical history: List any prior nasal surgery or injury, breathing trouble, current medications and supplements, and past reactions to anesthesia. Operative reports from earlier procedures are especially useful for revision cases.
- A list of questions: Written questions keep the visit focused, and the next section offers a starting set.
- Insurance information: Cosmetic rhinoplasty is not covered by insurance, but portions of a functional repair, such as correcting a deviated septum, may be eligible depending on your plan. New Face NY reviews costs with and without insurance during the consultation, assuming the office receives your insurance information prior to the day of consultation.
For background on who tends to be a good candidate, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons publishes an overview of ASPS rhinoplasty candidacy that is worth reading beforehand. At the visit itself, Dr. Westreich reviews your goals and breathing concerns and explains the surgical plan, including any limitations.
Questions to Ask Your Rhinoplasty Surgeon Before Booking
Specific questions draw more useful answers than general ones, so use this sample list and adapt it to your own priorities.
- How many rhinoplasties do you perform, and how many involve noses like mine?
- Do you prefer an open or closed approach, and why does it suit my anatomy?
- What is your revision policy, and what costs would apply if a touch-up is needed?
- Which type of anesthesia do you recommend, and who administers it?
- What does the total fee include, and which costs are billed separately?
Cost deserves a direct conversation. According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, the average cost of rhinoplasty is $7,637, a figure that excludes anesthesia, operating room facilities, and related expenses. ASPS rhinoplasty cost At New Face NY, anesthesia may be local, intravenous sedation, or general depending on the treatment plan, and Dr. Westreich uses Exparel, a long-acting numbing medication that may provide comfort for up to three days after surgery.
Ready for Your Rhinoplasty Consultation? Dr. Westreich Is Here to Help
Dr. Westreich is a Castle Connolly Top Doctor in facial plastic surgery, an assistant professor at SUNY Downstate Medical Center, and a former president of the New York Facial Plastic Surgery Society. To schedule a consultation at New Face NY on East 88th Street, contact the office directly, or choose to book online at a time that suits you.
This information is provided for educational purposes only and does not replace a consultation with a board-certified surgeon. Outcomes, risks, and suitability vary from patient to patient.

